Kate Hudson and Gwyneth Paltrow spilled the tea on their best and worst on-screen kisses on Gwyneth’s Goop podcast.

Gwyneth asked Kate “Who was the best on-screen kisser?” and Kate’s response was, “You know, I feel like I kind of haven’t had the best kissers. I feel like I should have had better ones.”

She went on to say that her smooches with frequent co-star Matthew McConaughey were always marred by circumstances.

“The thing is, every time I kiss McConaughey, it’s like, I mean, it’s like there’s just something happening and there’s like snot or wind, or things are just… like when we were kissing in the end of Fool’s Gold, we’re like in the ocean, we like had the plane crash. He just had snot all over his face.”

Gwyneth chimed it too about her co-star Robert Downey Jr saying, “Like with Robert, like when I kissed him and I was like, ‘You’ve got to be kidding me. This is literally like kissing my brother.”

So who were their favorites? According to Kate, her Almost Famous co-star Bill Crudup. The kiss didn’t make it into the movie though so does it count?

 

(PEOPLE)